\nAdvantage: Dobereiner give the concept of Dobereiner triads. He placed three elements having similar properties in the same group. These elements were arranged in increasing order of atomic mass and the mass of middle element was the average of the other two. \nLimitation: Only 4 triads were identified by him. He also failed to group nitrogen, phosphorus and arsenic because atomic mass of phosphorus is not the average of other two.
\n\n\n
\n
2. Newland: \nAdvantages: Newland arranged the elements in horizontal rows in order of increasing atomic mass such that the property of every 8th element was similar to that of 1st element. \nLimitation: His arrangement was only applicable to lighter elements having atomic masses upto 40.
\n
\n\n
\n
3. Mendeleev: \nAdvantage: He states that the properties of elements are the periodic functions of their atomic masses. He left some spaces in the periodic table for the discovery of new elements. \nLimitation: Position of hydrogen and isotopes were not justified in his periodic table.
\n
\n"},"comment":{"@type":"Comment","text":"Recall that Dobereiner, Newland and Mendeleev classified elements based on their atomic mass."},"encodingFormat":"text/markdown","learningResourceType":"Practice problem","suggestedAnswer":[],"text":"The modern periodic table has been evolved through the early attempts of Dobereiner, Newland and Mendeleev. List one advantage and one limitation of all the three attempts."},"name":"Quiz on Periodic Classification of Elements","typicalAgeRange":"10-17","url":"https://www.embibe.com/questions/The-modern-periodic-table-has-been-evolved-through-the-early-attempts-of-Dobereiner%2C-Newland-and-Mendeleev.-List-one-advantage-and-one-limitation-of-all-the-three-attempts./EM8477623"}
Embibe Experts Solutions for Chapter: Periodic Classification of Elements, Exercise 1: Exercise
Author:Embibe Experts
Embibe Experts Science Solutions for Exercise - Embibe Experts Solutions for Chapter: Periodic Classification of Elements, Exercise 1: Exercise
Attempt the practice questions on Chapter 5: Periodic Classification of Elements, Exercise 1: Exercise with hints and solutions to strengthen your understanding. Science Crash Course (Based on Revised Syllabus-2023) solutions are prepared by Experienced Embibe Experts.
Questions from Embibe Experts Solutions for Chapter: Periodic Classification of Elements, Exercise 1: Exercise with Hints & Solutions
The modern periodic table has been evolved through the early attempts of Dobereiner, Newland and Mendeleev. List one advantage and one limitation of all the three attempts.